ICE Stalks Santa Rita Jail, County Sends Strongly Worded Letter

ICE disregarded Alameda County’s anti-ICE rules. Will politicians do anything about it?

ICE Stalks Santa Rita Jail, County Sends Strongly Worded Letter
Two ICE agents make a point of filming the writer as she records them. (Amy Martyn/Bay Area Current)

A little before 5 p.m. on Sunday evening, a Dodge Durango with tinted windows and no license plates cruised through the parking lot of Santa Rita Jail in Dublin, California. As I filmed the vehicle driving away, it made a U-turn back in my direction. The window rolled down, revealing two men wearing vests labeled ICE. Both of their faces were covered, the driver with an American flag gaiter, the passenger with a simple black one. They both made a point of filming me as I recorded them. "You have a wonderful afternoon,” one said. Then they drove away as dramatically as they arrived.

0:00
/0:13

(Amy Martyn/Bay Area Current)

Since late October, federal immigration agents have been at the Santa Rita Jail parking lot daily. The agents have even entered the jail lobby to ask about case numbers and names, according to groups monitoring the situation, footage viewed by Current, and a visitor at the jail on Sunday.

One witness at the jail told Current that they saw a young man released from jail get taken by ICE at roughly 3 p.m. on Sunday.

“They’ve been here all week. I don’t believe there’s anything we can do,” said a Sheriff’s deputy at the front desk. 

The presence of ICE agents at Alameda County's main jail raises questions about the feel-good policies that were supposed to establish "ICE-Free Zones" throughout the county. Alameda County Sheriff Yesenia Sanchez has repeatedly said in public that her department would not cooperate with ICE.

"We don’t want to place fear on our undocumented residents," Sanchez said last year.

A spokesman for the Alameda County Sheriff's department did not respond to questions from Current as of publishing time. Sheriff's deputies that Current spoke to on Sunday seemed to believe that there was nothing they could do to keep ICE agents out of the jail parking lot or lobby. A Sheriff's deputy leaving work said he didn't think the department had any authority to ask the agents to leave. "It's a public space," he said. The parking lot is open to the public but is County-owned property. 

Two deputies said they could not even take the basic step of warning detainees about ICE's presence outside before they get released from jail. People in county jail are pretrial defendants, meaning they have not been convicted, and charges that land a person in a county jail are often minor or nonviolent.

"Where we are at is, we don't get involved," said Deputy J. Mazhar. 

On Tuesday afternoon, the Alameda County Sheriff's Department announced that it was closing its lobby to all people. An ICE agent chased someone into the lobby and arrested them on November 1, the department said. Separately, the Sheriff’s office said there was a “confrontation” between an ICE agent and members of the public. Video from the incident shows an ICE agent pushing a protester in the jail lobby.

In January, the Alameda County Board of Supervisors unanimously voted to create ICE-free zones to a crowd of cheering supporters. The policy specifically says that no county-owned property "including parking lots" can be used for civil immigration enforcement. Santa Rita Jail is Alameda county property, located in Dublin. 

"I am really proud to make a motion to ensure Alameda County stands firmly on the right side of justice, democracy, and protecting the dignity and humanity of all our residents,” Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas said at the time. Bas co-authored the policy with Supervisor Elisa Márquez.

Current reached out to Bas for comment on Monday afternoon. A few hours later, the Attorney for Alameda County sent ICE a cease and desist letter "demanding an immediate end to its unauthorized and unlawful use of County property near Santa Rita Jail for immigration enforcement." 

“Alameda County recognizes that Santa Rita Jail and all County property where services are provided are sensitive areas with many vulnerable individuals who could be fearful or harmed by ICE's presence,” Bas said in a press release. A representative for Bas has not yet responded to  follow-up questions from Current.

Representatives for Márquez and Supervisor David Haubert, whose district includes the Santa Rita Jail, have not yet responded to requests for comment. 

The extent of ICE arrests outside Santa Rita Jail is unclear. Volunteer observers and activists have been a regular presence at the jail, but county officials have not given ICE arrests at Santa Rita the same attention as other high-profile immigration cases, at least publicly. Lawyers with Alameda County Immigration Legal and Education Partnership (ACILEP), the county's rapid response hotline for immigration support, said in a meeting Tuesday that there have been four "confirmed" arrests outside Santa Rita Jail dating back to October 25 and other suspected arrests. 

"We encourage vulnerable community members to avoid areas near jails," ACILEP posted on October 30. But few people are "near jail" by choice. 

Once released from jail, former Santa Rita inmates may still have to attend hearings in the county’s criminal courts. ACILEP posted that someone was arrested by ICE on November 5 at the East County Hall of Justice, an Alameda County criminal courthouse that is roughly a mile from Santa Rita. It’s unclear if any county officials have been monitoring the courthouse since then to see if it’s safe for defendants to attend their hearings. 

People who were at Santa Rita on Monday night noticed some policy changes. The Sheriff's department closed its public lobby to all outsiders, civilians and ICE agents alike, forcing activists who hoped to warn anyone about ICE's presence to wait outside. ICE agents spent the night watching the scene unfold from the parking lot, according to an observer on the ground. 

(Anonymous observer/Bay Area Current)

At roughly 10 p.m., an ICE agent stepped out of his SUV and had a conversation with two sheriff's deputies, according to another volunteer observer. They said the conversation appeared to be amicable.

Have you recently seen, interacted with, or been detained by Immigration Customs Enforcement (ICE)? Call your local rapid response network. Here’s a list.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Bay Area Current.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.